THE
ENACTMENTS OF JUSTINIAN. THE NOVELS. |
~ XXIII ~ |
CONCERNING APPEALS, AND WITHIN WHAT TIME THEY SHOULD BE TAKEN. |
|
( S. P. Scott, The Civil Law, XVI, Cincinnati, 1932 ). |
The Emperor Justinian to Tribonian, Most Glorious Quaestor and twice Consul. |
PREFACE. |
As We are accustomed
to moderate the excessive severity of ancient laws, We think that it
is necessary to pursue this course in the present case with reference
to appeals. For the ancient law prescribed that anyone who conducted
his own case and lost it should have only two days in which to take
an appeal, but when this was done by means of an attorney, the time
could be extended to three days. We, however, have learned by experience
that this was productive of injury, for many men being ignorant of the
subtlety of the law, and thinking that an appeal could be brought within
three days, allowed the two days to elapse, and thereby lost their right.
Wherefore We have considered it necessary to apply a suitable remedy. |
CHAPTER I. |
Hence We order
that all appeals from the decisions of judges of either superior or
inferior jurisdiction (with the sole exception of the Sublime Praetorian
Prefects), whether instituted by the parties themselves or by their
attorneys, defenders, curators, or guardians, shall be filed within
ten days after the rendition of the judgment. We grant this term to
persons engaged in lawsuits in order to enable them to determine whether
they will take an appeal or not, and lest, through the influence of
fear, an appeal may be taken without proper consideration, a course
which would increase the number of appellants; but now all shall have
a sufficient time for deliberation, which will restrain the unreflecting
precipitancy of litigants. |
CHAPTER
II. CONSIDERING CONSULTATIONS. |
We
have provided that when an appeal is taken to Our Consistory, and the
hearing of the same has been deferred on account of the Emperor being
employed with the dispatch of public business, and the Senators cannot
be called together for this reason, the appeal shall not be exposed
to risk on this account. For how can the appellants be to blame when
the Emperor is occupied with other matters? Or who has sufficient authority
to compel the sovereign to convoke the Senators and other officials,
when he is unwilling to do so? When
anything of this kind happens, the case shall remain in abeyance until
the Emperor voluntarily calls together the Senators and nobles, and
allows the matter to be brought before him, and everything to proceed
as is customary. |
CHAPTER
III. CONCERNING APPEALS IN EGYPT, ASIA, PONTUS, AND ELSEWHERE. |
In
this, the third chapter, a matter must be disposed of which was settled
in ancient times, but has recently been neglected. For, formerly, when
magistrates of superior, intermediate, and inferior rank, were appointed,
appeals, when taken, instead of being brought before the superior magistrate,
were filed in the tribunal of the intermediate judges, who, together
with their associates, decided them. In modern times, however, this
course is no longer pursued, for Our judges of superior rank are annoyed
by appeals in cases of trifling importance, and litigants are subjected
to great expense where insignificant matters are involved, so that the
value of the entire property in controversy is not as much as the costs
incurred. Therefore We order that when an appeal is taken in Egypt,
or in either Lybia, in a case where an article is worth ten pounds of
gold, it shall not be brought to this royal city, but before the Augustal
Prefect, who shall hear and dispose of it instead of the Emperor, and
that no appeal can be taken after he has rendered a final decision. (1) In like manner, whenever, either in Asia or Pontus, an appeal is taken in an action where property to the aforesaid amount of ten pounds of gold is involved, it shall be brought before the Counts, Proconsuls, Praetors, or Governors whom We have especially authorized to hear it. These magistrates shall take the place of the Emperor, just as the Augustal Prefect does, and shall hear such suits and decide them, having the fear of God and the law before their eyes, without the right of further appeal. Cases which have been in abeyance in the East, because appeals have been taken, and which are limited to the said value of ten pounds of gold, shall be sent before the Count of the East, who shall hear and finally dispose of them. |
CHAPTER
IV. APPEALS FROM MAGISTRATES SHOULD BE BROUGHT BEFORE THOSE OF HIGHER RANK. |
It
must be observed that magistrates having the title of spectabiles, or
others invested with similar jurisdiction, cannot have their decisions
reviewed by other judges of the same rank, when appeals are taken, no
matter what may be the amount of the property involved (as appeals must
not be brought before judges of equal authority, but from the decisions
of those of inferior jurisdiction, to others of more exalted rank),
but by the Illustrious Prefect (as has already been stated), who with
the distinguished Quaestor in office at the time, shall decide them
with the assistance of their subordinates, that is to say, the employees
of the Imperial Bureau of Records and of the Praetorian Prefecture.
We make this provision in order that appeals from the Proconsuls or
other magistrates who, charged with no other public duties, have been
appointed by the Emperor, may not be brought indiscriminately before
the aforesaid judges without observing the distinction of rank.
We, however, desire that
appeals from the Governors of provinces and judges appointed by Us,
where the latter are not spectabiles, shall be restricted to cases where
the above-mentioned amount is involved. But where superior judges have
been appointed by Us whose rank is above that of those referred to,
or Proconsuls, or any other magistrates of equal official dignity who
have been commissioned by the Emperor, their appeals, no matter what
the value of the property in dispute may be, shall be brought to this
Imperial City, where competent magistrates will hear and determine them,
in conformity with ancient custom. Everything prescribed by the ancient
authorities, by former constitutions, or by Ourself, shall, in all other
matters relating to appeals, remain in full force and effect. |
Given at Constantinople, on the Kalends of July, after the Consulate of Belisarius. |
EPITOME OF
THE PRECEDING CONSTITUTION. CONCERNING MAGISTRATES TO WHOM APPEALS SHALL BE TAKEN WHEN THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY INVOLVED DOES NOT EXCEED TEN POUNDS OF GOLD. |
CHAPTER I. |
If
the time established by law should elapse without the appeal having
been heard by the Emperor, the case shall in no way be prejudiced. When
an appeal is taken to the Emperor either from Egypt or from either of
the Lybias, and the amount of property involved does not exceed ten
pounds of gold, the appeal shall be heard and decided by the Augustal
Prefect; in the East by the Count of the East; and in Pontus and Asia
by the Counts, Proconsuls, Praetors and Governors, if they have been
expressly charged with this duty. All these officials are hereby invested
with imperial authority for this purpose, and no one shall question
their jurisdiction when cases of this kind are brought before him. |
CHAPTER II. |
When
an appeal is taken from a Governor, whether the property in controversy
is worth more or less than ten pounds of gold, the Praetorian Prefect,
along with the Qusestor and other officials, shall take cognizance of
the same. |
|