THE ENACTMENTS OF JUSTINIAN.
  
THE NOVELS.
~  XV  ~
CONCERNING THE DEFENDERS OF CITIES.



 
S. P. Scott, The Civil Law, XVI, Cincinnati, 1932 ).
 

 
The Emperor Justinian to John, Most Glorious Praetorian Prefect, twice Consul and Patrician.
PREFACE.
  Unless We make haste to recall the defenders of cities to the performance of their duties, their ancient titles will no longer be applicable; for, as formerly, names indicative of their functions were given to magistrates, and that of defender certainly indicates that such officials were charged with seeing that no injustice was committed; so in like manner, in paternal language We style them defenders, because they were appointed to defend persons suffering from the acts of wicked men. When, however, the name of defender is treated with contempt in many parts of Our Empire, and is so despised that its use is rather considered an insult than a distinction; the reason for which is that it is not so much a judicious choice as pity which is responsible for such appointments, they being conferred upon obscure men who have nothing to live upon, and who obtain these employments by solicitation. Then, defenders are entirely dependent upon the Governors, by whom they are removed at will, without any reasons, or on insufficient grounds, and are then replaced by others, who are treated merely as holders of the position; and as many removals take place during the same year, the result is that the officials, the municipal magistrates, and the citizens themselves have not the slightest respect for the defenders, nor is any confidence reposed in the documents which they execute, and which the defenders themselves refuse to draw up if the Governor forbids them to do so; for, being absolutely subjected to his authority, they comply with his slightest inclinations. When documents are drawn up by them in the first place, they only do this for money; and then, as there are no archives in which these documents can be deposited, they are lost; and no monuments of former times are ever found in the possession of those who receive them, but when a demand is made upon their heirs or other successors, they either do not have them, or where any are found they are not worthy of consideration, or have been defaced to such an extent that they can no longer be deciphered. Therefore, as We have already decreed with reference to Governors, to whom We have granted great authority in the provinces, and who should exercise supervision over cities at a distance, We think that it is necessary to also regulate the conduct of defenders, and We believe that the relations existing between these officials will be advantageous to both, if We confer judicial authority upon the defenders of cities, for then the Governor of a province will be regarded as a judge of judges, and his office will appear more honorable than formerly, in accordance with the rule that the distinction of a superior magistrate is always increased in proportion to that of an inferior one.
CHAPTER I.
   
NO INHABITANT OF A CITY SHALL BE PERMITTED TO REFUSE THE OFFICE OF DEFENDER.
  Notice is hereby given, in the first place, that no man shall be allowed to reject the appointment of defender, and that all the nobles of cities shall be required to exercise its functions regularly in their turn, for We have learned that in the early ages of the Republic this course was productive of great benefit, hence no person can decline this office, even when he belongs to the rank of those who are styled illustrious, or is invested with a military employment, or can plead some privilege bestowed by the Imperial enactments, or produces a pragmatic sanction authorizing such an exemption. A list of the principal inhabitants alternately eligible for the office of defender shall be drawn up, and when this list has been exhausted, each one of those included therein shall again begin to discharge the same public functions in his order; and this is provided in order that he who occupies this position in any city shall rather be considered as a judge than a defender. When the list is to be drawn up, all owners of property resident in the city, with the exception of those who do not have their domicile therein, shall be sworn.
  (1) The defender who is about to assume office shall swear to perform his duties in accordance with law, and without distinction of persons, and shall (as is at present the case) be confirmed by Our Glorious Prefect. He shall remain in office two years, after the expiration of which time he shall be replaced by someone else; the Governor of the province shall not be authorized to remove him, but if he should not discharge his duty properly, the prefects must be notified, so that he may be dismissed by the same officials who appointed him.
CHAPTER II.
  We absolutely forbid Governors as well as defenders to cause substitutes for themselves to be appointed. For We do not wish magistrates in cities to be succeeded by any other persons than defenders, who alone shall represent them, and should exert all their efforts for the welfare of the cities in which they reside.
CHAPTER III.
   
ALL DOCUMENTS SHALL BE REGISTERED BY DEFENDERS.
  All wills, donations, and other documents of this kind shall be registered by defenders; and no Governor of a province shall prohibit any instrument from being drawn up or published, for We do not grant permission for anything of this kind to be done. We think it would be most absurd for men to be compelled to refrain from necessary transactions, in accordance with the unreasonable wishes of the authorities; and We desire full liberty to be granted everyone to make any contract he wishes, and publish the same; and even if what is done has reference to the Governor of the province, or to any other official, it still shall not be forbidden. For those who are in charge of the government, or hold some position of responsibility, should conduct themselves so as not to prevent any charge from being brought against themselves, but, on the other hand, they should render their conduct so irreproachable that no occasion may exist for such- complaints to be made; and whether the Governor is in the city or not, no one shall be prohibited from filing documents with the defenders in any matter whatsoever, with the exception of such as are not in his jurisdiction, but belong to that of the Governor.
  (1) Again, the defenders of cities shall, along with the other officials charged with this duty, collect taxes, and if anyone should prove refractory, and refuse to pay what is due, they must draw up the papers necessary under the circumstances; and We order that this shall be done without delay; and also that they exercise strict supervision over persons of bad behavior, and obtain evidence against them. They must also repress all public sedition, and, in every respect, exercise the functions of judges, especially when the latter are absent; and all the officials of the province who are in the city where the defender exercises his authority are required to obey and assist him, so that where the Governor is away, his presence will not seem to be necessary. Defenders shall have a clerk subject to their orders, as well as two officers to carry their decrees into execution.
  (2) Defenders shall have jurisdiction in all pecuniary cases where the sum involved is not more than three hundred aurei; and Our subjects shall not be permitted to appeal to the illustrious Governors of provinces, where the amount in controversy is less than the aforesaid sum.
CHAPTER IV.
  A plaintiff shall not estimate the property in dispute in excess of its real value, for the purpose of avoiding the jurisdiction of the defender, and bringing his action before the Governor of the province. If anyone should commit an act of this kind, and the judgment shows that the property in litigation was worth less than three hundred aurei, and that its value had been designedly increased in order to bring the case before the Governor of the province, and prevent the defender of the city from deciding it, the plaintiff shall be liable to all the costs of litigation.
CHAPTER V.
  Appeals from the decisions of defenders of cities shall be brought before Governors. When officials are guilty of any abuse of defenders the Governors of provinces can punish them. If the Governors should fail to do this, We grant the defenders permission to have recourse to Your Highness, who will afford them any relief which may be proper. Defenders are authorized to prosecute persons guilty of crime, just as Governors can do.
  (1) When the office of defender of a city becomes vacant, it shall immediately be bestowed upon the person next on the list, who shall be sworn, and shall be confirmed by letters from Your Highness. We (as has previously been stated) by no means desire that defenders shall be permitted to substitute anyone in their places, lest, if this should be done, matters will again be involved in confusion.
  (2) Your Highness will issue orders in every province for a building to be furnished in which the defenders can keep their documents, and someone must be selected to have charge of the same, in order to prevent their destruction, and enable them quickly to be found by persons desiring to inspect them; and thus archives will be provided for the defenders, and what hitherto has been lacking in cities will be supplied.
CHAPTER VI.
  As the defenders of cities discharge the duties of their office without any compensation, when they are residents of a large city, they shall not pay more than four aurei to the court of Your Highness for their letters, and where they hold office in smaller towns, they will only be required to pay three aurei, as has already been prescribed by Our laws; but where they are paid by the public, they shall continue to receive their salaries, as has been customary.
  (1) Defenders shall take cognizance of minor offences, and inflict proper punishment for their commission. Where persons are arrested for serious crimes, they shall place them in prison, and then send them to the Governor of the province, so that in this way every town will enjoy the benefit of a judicial examination. The entire province, being under the jurisdiction of a superior magistrate of high rank, will experience the beneficial effect of his wise administration, and the great care that Governors take for the benefit of those subject to them will be diminished, for the reason that defenders, in devoting all their attention to their own cities, will prevent oppression; remove the doubts which arise in the transaction of business; and (as has been often stated) will communicate to the government the names of persons who discharge their duties with fidelity. When anyone opposes the levy of taxes, the Governors shall order the defenders to proceed against him, and they shall take measures to do so. Where, however, the appointment of a defender is made in any other way than the one prescribed, or someone appointed to this position in the order in which his name appears on the list refuses to assume its duties, whether this be on account of his dignity, his military rank, some special privilege, or for any other reason whatsoever, he shall be liable to a penalty of five pounds of gold, and after the defender then in office retires, he shall be compelled to take his place. For it is proper that this employment should always be exercised by the most distinguished inhabitants of the city in return for the residence which it affords them.
EPILOGUE.
  Your Highness will, by means of special proclamations publish throughout the provinces in your jurisdiction the provisions which We have determined to enact and promulgate by means of this Imperial law, in order that everyone, no matter what his rank or fortune, may become aware that Our solicitude extends to all persons, and that there is nothing to which We do not direct Our attention. Your Highness will issue orders to the Governors of provinces, and they, as soon as they have received them, will see that in every city a list of the most distinguished citizens who are eligible to perform the duties of defender is drawn up (as has already been stated), and that general appointments are made followed by the prescribed oath; to the end that the names in the list may be determined, and that, for the future, defenders may continue to exercise their functions for the term of two years; and that, finally, when each one of those included in the said list for any reason fails to act, another may immediately be introduced in his stead (always after having taken the oath), whose selection shall be made by the bishop, the venerable members of the clergy, and other persons of good reputation in the city. These provisions, embodied in a general law, shall (as already has been stated) hereafter be complied with in every respect. Defenders who are at present in office shall, if considered worthy, be included in the list, and shall serve the remaining portion of the two years, and in case their term of office has expired, they shall be replaced by others, provided that they themselves are not reappointed for another term of two years. If, then, such defenders as are considered eligible have not served the entire two years of their term, they shall do so, and, after the said term has elapsed, none of them shall remain in office; and when (as has just been stated) a defender is reappointed with the consent of the entire city, and without any opposition, he shall serve another term of two years, at the expiration of which time he shall retire without being eligible to reappointment, until his term again arrives, which rule We establish in order not to confer too much authority upon anyone by the frequency and duration of his terms of office. This law shall be valid for all time, as We have drawn it up with the greatest zeal and care, and after having implored Divine assistance, We have communicated it to Our subjects.
Given at Constantinople, on the sixteenth of the Kalends of August, during the Consulate of Belisarius.